| Tier 4 Award Finalists | |
| Top 3 Vote Getters (including Ties) | |
| - alphabetical order (last name) | |
| Most Valuable Player | |
| Colin Kargus | Coyotes |
| Nick Lenardon | DMI Rockets |
| Phil Martin | Black Sock |
| Steve Rumleskie | Dukes |
| Best Batter | |
| Colin Kargus | Coyotes |
| Phil Martin | Black Sox |
| Ross Randleman | Braumeisters |
| Best Pitcher | |
| Mike Bayley | DMI Rockets |
| Colin Kargus | Coyotes |
| Steve Rumleskie | Dukes |